Choosing a nurse staffing agency is not just a way to fill an open shift. For an ambulatory surgery center (ASC), staffing decisions affect clinical coverage, scheduling, staff workload, and the center’s use of resources. A strong agency relationship should support those needs, not create more work for your team.

The best fit will depend on your case mix, the roles you need covered, and whether the need is temporary or ongoing. Use the criteria below to compare agencies on specialty fit, clinical readiness, reliability, and cost, not just the hourly rate.

1. Start with your center’s actual staffing need

Before contacting agencies, define the gap you want to address. A request for “an OR nurse” may not give an agency enough information to identify an appropriate candidate.

Document the role, schedule, expected start date and duration, and the skills needed for your service lines. Consider whether coverage is required in the OR, pre-op, PACU, endoscopy, sterile processing, cath lab, or another procedural area. Specify any call or weekend expectations, required certifications, relevant systems or equipment, and the experience needed for your patient population and case mix.

Also identify what is driving the request. A short-term leave, hard-to-fill vacancy, rising overtime, and planned service-line expansion are different problems. They may call for different staffing approaches.

A staffing partner should ask questions about these circumstances before recommending a solution. That early discussion helps reduce mismatches and makes it easier to assess whether temporary coverage, direct hire, or another approach may fit.

ASC leaders discussing staffing needs in a bright healthcare setting

2. Look for relevant perioperative and procedural experience

General healthcare recruiting experience does not necessarily mean an agency understands ASC staffing. Ask how it recruits and evaluates professionals for the specialties you need.

Useful questions include:

A résumé and active license are important, but they do not establish facility-specific competency. For example, an OR RN may have experience in a different service line, facility size, or workflow than yours. Your leaders should review each candidate’s background against the assignment requirements.

The CMS ASC conditions for coverage state that nursing services must be directed and staffed so patient needs are met, responsibilities are delineated, and recognized standards of practice are followed. CMS also says that contracted services must be provided safely and effectively. These responsibilities make it important to agree on how the agency and ASC will each contribute to candidate review and onboarding.

3. Clarify credentialing, orientation, and competency

Ask the agency to explain its credentialing process and what documentation it can provide for each candidate. Depending on the role and applicable requirements, this may include license verification, certifications, work history, background checks, health clearances, and relevant skills or competency records. Confirm how credentials are checked, how expirations are monitored, and how you can review the file before the start date.

Then clarify what happens after a candidate arrives. The agency’s screening process is not a substitute for your ASC’s own orientation and approval. Define who provides facility-specific training, who validates competence, and who decides whether a clinician is ready to work independently.

AORN’s position statement on perioperative orientation discusses role- and scope-specific competency assessment and tailored orientation. It also notes that the statement does not apply to contracted travelers, so use it as a reference point, not as a rule for every staffing arrangement. Your facility’s policies, applicable regulations, and the assignment agreement should guide the process.

Perioperative nurse educator orienting a colleague in an outpatient operating room

4. Assess reliability and communication

A candidate’s qualifications matter, but so does the agency’s ability to communicate and respond when plans change. Ask how it handles call-outs, late cancellations, schedule changes, and concerns about performance. Find out who your point of contact will be and how after-hours issues are escalated.

Request specific measures the agency tracks, such as time to present candidates, fill rate, call-off frequency, replacement time, and assignment completion. Ask how often it will review those measures with your team. These figures are most useful when definitions are clear and relevant to your center’s needs.

A reliable agency should also have a process for communicating incidents or concerns involving its placed clinicians. Your agreement should set expectations for timely notification and cooperation with your internal review process.

5. Compare the full cost, not only the bill rate

The lowest quoted rate may not represent the lowest overall cost. Review the rate structure alongside the time your team will spend interviewing, credentialing, orienting, and supervising a clinician. Consider the possible effects of uncovered shifts, cancellations, repeated onboarding, overtime, or a poor role match.

Ask each agency for a written breakdown of:

Compare proposals using the same role requirements, schedule, and assumptions. If terms are unclear, request clarification before selection. Transparent pricing makes it easier to evaluate the real tradeoffs and manage resources responsibly.

6. Review the contract before placements begin

A written agreement should make responsibilities clear. In addition to rates and billing, review provisions covering candidate qualifications, credential documentation, orientation, supervision, reporting concerns, confidentiality, insurance, cancellation, replacements, and the process for ending an assignment.

Be sure the agreement explains who can remove a clinician from an assignment if there is a safety or performance concern, and how quickly the agency will respond. Have appropriate internal stakeholders review the terms. This may include nursing leadership, HR, procurement, compliance, and legal counsel.

7. Choose a staffing model that fits the need

The best nurse staffing agency should help you evaluate options rather than defaulting to one placement type. Temporary or per diem coverage may help address a short-term gap or variable demand. Direct hire recruitment may be more suitable when the need is permanent. A bridge-to-hire arrangement may warrant consideration when you want temporary coverage while assessing a longer-term fit.

Acquire MedStaff provides temporary and contract staffing, direct hire, bridge-to-hire, and specialized perioperative and procedural staffing. The right approach will depend on the center’s circumstances; external staffing may not be the answer to every workforce challenge.

Bright, welcoming outpatient surgery center waiting area

A practical agency comparison checklist

Use the same questions for every agency you evaluate:

Area What to assess
Specialty fit Does the agency understand your roles, service lines, schedule, and case mix?
Candidate review Can it explain how it evaluates experience and shares candidate information?
Credentialing Are responsibilities, documentation, and expiration monitoring clear?
Orientation Is facility-specific training and competency validation planned?
Reliability Are call-outs, replacement expectations, and escalation paths defined?
Cost Are rates, add-on fees, cancellation terms, and conversion fees transparent?
Partnership Will the agency review performance and adjust to changing needs?

You can also begin with an internal review of where coverage is most vulnerable. Acquire MedStaff’s ASC Staffing Risk Scorecard is an educational assessment intended to help leaders identify areas for further evaluation; it is not a validated diagnostic instrument or a recommendation to use outside staffing.

Choose for fit, accountability, and continuity

A good staffing relationship should make responsibilities visible, support appropriate clinical review, and give your team a clear way to address problems. Before choosing an agency, confirm that its specialty experience fits your center, that credentialing and orientation expectations are understood, and that costs and service measures are transparent.

For a practical discussion of your ASC’s staffing needs and possible approaches, connect with Acquire MedStaff.